Category: Libri & Verbis

  • Howl’s No. 7: The Age of Surveillance Capitalism

    Howl’s No. 7: The Age of Surveillance Capitalism

    Author: Shoshana Zuboff

    Zuboff’s message is simple – our freedom is at stake – as the lords of Silicon Valley use our personal data to control what we see and do and the position that we are afforded in society. No longer ‘cogs’ in the machine we have been rendered as bytes in algorithms of code, with the future of democratic society under direct threat.  

    “Many adjectives could be used to describe Shoshana Zuboff’s latest book: groundbreaking, magisterial, alarming, alarmist, preposterous. One will do: unmissable… As we grope around in the darkness trying to grasp the contours of our digital era, The Age of Surveillance Capitalism shines a searing light on how this latest revolution is transforming our economy, politics, society – and lives.”―John Thornhill, FINANCIAL TIMES 

  • Howl’s No. 8: Freak Kingdom

    Howl’s No. 8: Freak Kingdom

    Author: Timothy Denevi

    A new perspective on ‘Raoul Duke’ aka Hunter S. Thompson, the drug-addled, wise guy critic of the American dream re-cast as a crusader, seeking to uphold what he believed American could be—and should not become. Denevi’s book puts Thompson’s antics and writing in a new light: a relentless (and inspiring) effort to confront hypocrisy and injustice with the best weapons that Thompson owned – his writing and humour. 

    “Freak Kingdom…sheds new light on Thompson’s politically awakening and reporting — and the toll it took on him and his later work and life. Few books this season will give you a stronger and more chilling sense of déjà vu…The book chronicles, in absorbing day-by-day detail, how Thompson intersected with history more than some may recall.”Rolling Stone

  • Howl’s No. 9 – The Ministry of Truth

    Howl’s No. 9 – The Ministry of Truth

    Author: Dorian Lynskey

    What more could the ‘thinking’ bibliophile ask for in 2019! 

    A book about a book that was, and remains, one of the greatest novels of the twentieth century as well as the perfect harbinger of our ‘post truth’ age.

    Dorian Lynskey’s The Ministry of Truth explores the epochal and cultural event that is George Orwell’s 1984, from its roots in the author’s own life and experiences and the utopian and dystopian literature that preceded it, through to the cultural and political fires that the novel ignited upon publication. Lynskey’s work, predictably, raises themes that have taken on new meaning in our ‘alternative facts’ age. 

    “A rich and compelling case for the novel as the summation of Orwell’s entire body of work and a master key to understanding the modern world. . . Lynskey’s account of the reach of 1984 is revelatory.”—George Packer, The Atlantic 

  • HOWL’s No. 10: The Last Stone

    HOWL’s No. 10: The Last Stone

    Mark Bowden

    The author of Black Hawk Down delivers the real-crime book of 2019. On March 29, 1975, sisters Katherine and Sheila Lyon, age 10 and 12, vanished from a shopping mall in suburban Washington, D.C. Despite the dedicated efforts of law enforcement the disappearances remained unsolved until 2013, when a cold case squad detective found something he and a generation of detectives had missed. Unlike recent resolved cold cases this is not a tale of DNA and ‘new’ science but a story of good ‘old fashion’ detective work and the last clue—the metaphoric last stone—that was finally turned 38 years after Katherine and Sheila disappeared into the D.C. afternoon haze. 

    HOWL says: “With the pace of a intricate thriller, Last Stone is a cerebral tale that keeps you riveted, from the first page to the last. A return to form from Bowden.”

    “In The Last Stone, Bowden focuses on 21 months of questioning by a revolving cast of detectives, telling a stirring, suspenseful, thoughtful story that, miraculously, neither oversimplifies the details nor gets lost in the thicket of a four-decade case file. This is a cat-and-mouse tale, told beautifully. But like all great true crime, The Last Stone finds its power not by leaning into cliché but by resisting it ― pushing for something more realistic, more evocative of a deeper truth. In this case, Bowden shows how even the most exquisitely pulled-off interrogations are a messy business, in which exhaustive strategizing is followed by game-time gut decisions and endless second-guessing and soul-searching.”―Robert Kolker, The New York Times

  • ‘But I’m Not Creative’

    ‘But I’m Not Creative’

    Sue Guiney, founder and CEO of Writing Through, offers some words on what inspires her organisation and its vision of fostering education and self-esteem through creative writing.

    ‘I’m not creative.’ So many people have said that to me, and I’m always upset to hear it. They say it when I suggest they might want to write a poem or story themselves. They say it when I describe how I founded Writing Through, the international educational non-profit that uses creative writing to help develop thinking skills, language fluency and self-esteem. ‘Oh, I could never do what you’ve done,’ they say. ‘I’m not creative.’  But I say, ‘Don’t be silly. Of course you are creative. We all are.’ We all just need the skills to unlock our creative impulses and the courage to try. That is what Writing Through does.

    Twelve years ago I travelled to Cambodia with my family, and I fell in love – with the people, their fascinating culture, their beautiful country despite their tragic history. That trip inspired me to write a novel – I can’t help it; that’s what I do – and the publication of that novel, which is called A Clash of Innocentsand is now the first in a trilogy of novels, encouraged me to bring the creative result of that inspiration back to the country which inspired me. To do that, I offered a modified version of a writing workshop I had been teaching in the UK to a shelter for street kids in Siem Reap. Twelve years later, that one workshop has now turned into an organisation reaching thousands of marginalized and at-risk people throughout three countries in Southeast Asia.

    We teach our workshops throughout Cambodia, Vietnam and Singapore, and we are moving towards expanding beyond the region, as well. And what is it that we do? We convince the people who participate in our specialized workshops that they are, indeed, creative, plus we give them the tools to access that creativity. We then give them the freedom to express their creative thoughts in words, in English, a language they have often felt was far beyond their reach.

    How do we do this? Over the years we have created and honed our programme of workshops which take well-known, proven techniques and combines them in a way which encourages, empowers, and stimulates all within a fun and often silly environment. We do this through the magic of creative writing.

    We at Writing Through know that experiencing the arts first-hand, and especially the literary arts of writing poetry and stories, is a key to developing thinking skills. So many of us have experienced the classroom as a place of fear. In our workshops, we take that fear away and replace it with fun and encouragement. So many of us have found ourselves in educational systems which are based on the rote repetition of information without having the chance to consider our own thoughts.

    Instead of giving answers in our workshops, we ask questions, over and over, encouraging deeper, more creative responses. Too many of us live lives where the arts are a distant experience reserved for others somehow ‘better’ than us. Writing Through hands these people a ‘magic pencil’, a blank piece of paper and says, ‘Go.’ Try.’ ‘Yes, you can.’ Then we give our students a forum in which to stand up and say aloud, sometimes for the very first time, who they are and what they think. That experience is life changing, both for the writer and for the audience.

    The word No is the death knell of creativity. To untap the creativity that is within all of us, we must first find the courage to say Yes. I have been personally lucky enough to have been given the time, the tools, and the encouragement to say Yes. In Writing Through our goal is to impart that gift of Yesto all our students, regardless of their age, nationality or life circumstances – and we aim to do it, one poem, one story at a time.

  • Something in the air

    Something in the air

    The revival of poetry in Cambodia and beyond

    One Eleven – Presage

    It’s 8:30 PM on a Saturday and One Eleven Gallery is pumping. From across the traffic island a combination of applause, shouts and the occasional ‘howl’ chop through the humid night air; lines of rhyme and verse filling the monsoon twilight like word-lit fireflies, flicking and darting, invigorated by the will of an appreciative crowd and not a little amount of alcohol. The HOWL Word Jam 2019 is in full swing, the gathered ensemble spilling out onto the verges of the footpath while, in the sky overhead, flashes of lightening forewarn of a wet season deluge. 

    Inside, standing before the microphone, dressed in a long red sweat top, Nisha is regaling us with a poem that, twelve hours before, did not exist. A participant in a morning creative writing workshop, facilitated by Writing Through, her artistic energies have birthed a poem that unfolds like a beautiful wave.

    You are my Saturn, the ring around my heart,

    You are my Mars; the fear is in your eyes,

    You are my Earth; you are as lively as an angel.

    You are my Venus, the goddess of love and belief,

    You are my Sun, the light that shines on my whole world. 

    With her last words still echoing from the speaker the crowd erupts with applause. Still standing Nisha appears shocked; unable to fathom, it seems, how words she crafted can evocate such a reaction. She nervously covers her mouth and gives an appreciative nod, while behind her palm a broad smile slowly fills her young Khmer face, surprise giving way to delight. 

    This Thing Called ‘Poetry’ 

    Poetry: What to make of this sanctified and other times maligned literature form, a form that seems to navigate its way between peaks and troughs?

    During its dip moments poetry can seem elitist and obscure, something clichéd and sentimental perhaps, writing that—either way— is irrelevant to the wider populous.

    During its peak moments, however, poetry can seem like a tidal wave—a force inspiring and driving expression; a creative surge setting fire to the cafes, bookstores and performance stages where it fines a home.

    More often, however, poetry seems to just meander along, persisting with a resting heartbeat; known to those who value such things while the rest of us carry on with life.

    Currently, though, poetry appears to be enjoying one of its ‘up-swing’ moments. In part this has evolved from the ease of online sharing and distribution, the typical poem being ideal for the attention span and cell-phone screens of the average reader.

    Across Australasia, Canada and the United Kingdom this momentum has coalesced around a bevy of young female writers (more here). They include Hera Lindsay Bird (NZ) who burned up the internet with her poem Keats is Dead so Fuck Me from Behind; Rupi Kaur, a 26-year-old Canadian-Punjabi, who dominated bestseller lists in 2018; and the slightly older Carol Duffy, the UK’s first female poet laureate. These and other women poets have attracted millions of online supporters, the internet permitting them to buy-pass the traditional male-centric publishing houses and capture a new range of attentive readers. 

    Poetry and the Kingdom 

    In Cambodia poetry seems to be experiencing its own moment of upward popularity. In truth there has been little where-else for the form to go, the period of genocide and civil war having gutted the country of the educators who had previously nurtured poetry in the kingdom’s schools and universities. In the following years the necessity of family has encouraged parents to push their offspring into the commercial, hospitality and administrative sectors, depriving their progeny of the opportunity to explore poetry, even recreationally.

    This is not to say that Cambodia has never had a healthy poetry community. Poetry was openly encouraged during the golden years of the 1960s, the creative arts flourishing under the patronage of the late King Father Norodom Sihanouk. During this period writers, such as Kong Bunchhoeun—one of the revered poets of the era—moved between song and filmmaking, novels and poetry to earn their reil and fuel their muse.

    Cambodia has also been the destination for numerous international poets, arguably the most famous being the beat writer Allen Ginsberg; the man who launched ‘a thousand berets’ with his signature work Howl (a poem that has inspired a certain Siem Reap-based word pop-up). Ginsberg travelled to Siem Reap in 1962, visiting the revered temples as part of a wider spiritual odyssey that had already taken him to India and elsewhere in the Far East. Ginsberg, as poets do, chose to capture his temple experience in the long-form poem Ankor Wat (sic)—published by Fulcrum Press, complete with photographs by Alexandra Lawrence—in 1969. It is a long meandering work that suggests Ginsberg partook in some of the local herb before his temple excursions. The beat master seemed to be particularly taken by Ta Prohm, the temple’s famous vista of intertwined roots and stone offering perfect fodder for Ginsberg predilection for druggy symbols and metaphors. 

    The huge snake roots, the vaster

                      Serpent arms fallen 

                      octopus over the roof

                      in a square courtyard-curved

                      roofcombs looked Dragon-back-stone-scaled

    As frail as stone is, this harder wooden 

                      Life crushing them. 

    Moving to the contemporary and the local, the current revival of poetry is being driven by developments at the grass roots, with organisations and learning centres, alongside the energy of motivated individuals, leading the way. Foremost at the former level is the inspirational work of Writing Through, an NGO devoted to nurturing thinking skills, self-esteem and language fluency through creative writing, with a specific focus on youngsters from populations ‘at risk’ (besides Cambodia the organisation also works in Singapore and Vietnam).

    In September a selection of poems by former Writing Through students was published in an anthology, the first such publication by the organisation, each of its collected works offering a unique window into the lives of its young authors – their hopes, fears and their dreams for the future. The book is a noteworthy achievement and a testament, not only to the Writing Through mission of “saving minds, one poem, one story at a time”, but also the dignity of the students striving for a notion of the past and a future in the heartlands of the kingdom:  

    I get a lot of problems in my life

    But I never leave my dream

    I’m not afraid of my mistakes

    Life is short, make it beautiful.

    (Love the way I Am, Srey, 10, Cambodia)

    A different contribution to the revival has come via the way of LiterTree, an enterprise featuring five 13 – 14 year-old female students from the Liger Leadership Academy, who have developed the computer app Naeng-Norng (‘Rhyme and Rhythm’). The application works as a tool that budding Khmer poets can use to help them craft their work, its features including platforms for sharing and discussing poems, advice on poetry structure and even a search function that allows users to find Khmer rhyming words. In September the innovative worth of the application was recognised at no less a venue than Silicon Valley, California, where the app was awarded second place at the annual World Pitch event.

    Elsewhere in the kingdom other individuals have made it their mission to ensure that the poets of old have not faded from sight. Significant here has been the effort by Puy Kea to collect and publish the works of Krom Ngoy (1864 – 1936), a man considered by many to be the father of Khmer poetry. Krom’s importance to Cambodia poetry is underpinned by the experiences of those born and raised in the kingdom prior to the Khmer Rouge, where a common memory was the reciting of his poems by parents and teachers. Despite such significance Kea was disheartened to learn that much of Krom’s poems were in danger of disappearing forever, with only a few tattered copies of his printed works remaining. Searching out what he could find Kea, in 2016, published a single volume of Krom’s poetry, the publication being widely distributed following its release. 

    A number of other Cambodians are making poetry waves that have gone beyond the kingdom. Kosal Khiev, ‘Cambodia’s Son’, is probably the best known of the artists who have nurtured an international and local following, helped in part by the success of a film documenting his life as well as the man’s infectious creativity and performance – few can tire of a Kosal Khiev open-mic. 

    Lesser known in Cambodia, despite achieving broad international recognition, is Lang Leav, a child of the Thai border camps who later emigrated to the more restive environs of Australia and then, later, New Zealand. In the Antipodes she found her voice and has published several collections, including Sea and Strangers and Love Looks Pretty on You. Leav’s mediations on love, relationships and writing have found a keen international audience, especially amongst young adult readers—making her one of New Zealand’s top selling international poets—much to the consternation of some of this country’s literati who consider her musings ‘naïve’ and ‘tweed’. Having stumbling on two of her volumes in a popular Hong Kong bookshop—I had never heard of Leav until that point—I find her writing compelling and thoughtful; certainly more worthy of public acclaim than critical derision.

    I thought of you with

    My heart already broken;

    I thought of you

    as it was breaking again.

    I think of you now,

    as I am healing.

    With somebody new—

    I’ll think of you then.

    (‘Forever on my Mind’, Lang Leav, from Sea of Strangers)

    There is much more going on than I can cover here with workshops, festivals and collectives sprouting up around the kingdom—some living, others dying—as the muse takes hold. Poetry appears to be moving upward and it remains to see where this may lead, but for sure it promises to be an interesting ride. 

    One Eleven – Reprise

    Jess gives a stirring recital that burns the state image of Singapore; Mick speaks of creativity in an accelerated age; Wayne remembers fallen heroes and Christie reminisces, but it is Sabhor who enjoys the most popular cheer of the night. Another graduate of the morning’s Writing Through workshop his assured delivery on the fate of a squirrel belies the nervousness he showed prior to his moment in the spotlight. At the night’s end he is the resounding winner of the audience choice award, his beaming face joining his alumni colleague, Nisha, who is awarded the second runners up spot for her ode to the universe and love. 

    Outside the rain has stopped while inside the microphone has been switched off but One Eleven is still humming. This year’s word jam has made us laugh, ponder, perhaps spring a hidden tear, but most of all it has made us HOWL – to cry out and celebrate words composed, given life and set free into the monsoon night.

    Poetry is alive in the kingdom
    See you next year. 

  • How Did We Get Here?

    How Did We Get Here?

    American Carnage: 
    On the Front Lines of the Republican Civil War 
    and the Rise of President Trump

    Author Tim Alberta

    Part I: 
    All Hail the PoT (Party of Trump)

    “ The politician will be only too happy to abdicate in favour of his image, because the image will be so much more powerful than he could ever be.” Marshall McLuhan (interview, 1972)

    Through the long journey across the primaries and into the US presidential election in 2016 it seemed unlikely, no impossible, that come January 2017 Donald J. Trump Jr. would find himself sitting behind the Resolute desk in the Oval Office. The consummate salesman, his skills honed through reality TV, it felt like a massive charade with we, the audience, waiting for the man to break into a grin, to offer a wink, before announcing: “just kidding folks”. I guess Donald was not in on the joke.

    Over the last three years an extensive number of books have been published detailing the rise of Donald Trump and the first years of his presidential term. Some writers—Michael Wolff’s Fire and Fury. Inside the Trump Whitehouse is an example—have gone for the low bar; its hotwire into the Whitehouse, Steve Bannon (or ‘Sloppy Steve’ as the Trump now calls him) ensuring that the book was not threatened by scholarly intent; other publications—such as Bob Woodward’s Fear. Trump in the Whitehouse—have brought a reasoned and articulate analysis to the subject. In other cases, Matt Taibbi’s Insane Clown President is a personal favourite, writers have used gallows humour to detail the bewildering situation. 

    Tim Alberta’s American Carnage: On the Front Lines of the Republican Civil War and the Rise of President Trump is a different beast—and at 680-odd pages it has more than the hint of Godzilla about it—for at its centre lies not the president but the Republican Party; a party, Alberta argues, that Trump has captured and reshape into his own image.

    “Rarely has a president so thoroughly altered the identity of his party. Never has a president so ruthlessly exploited the insecurity of his people.” 

    This is a party known as much by its acronym—GOP (the Grand Old Party)—as by its Republican title; a political collective that begat us Abraham Lincoln, Theodore Roosevelt, Dwight D. Eisenhower and ‘ahem’ Richard Nixon; and which, over the course of 150 years, has championed a conservative agenda of lower taxes / less government, free trade, the global world order (remember the Neocons) and strong families, all underpinned by a healthy dose of individual ‘can-do-ism’. 

    Now, in the space of eleven years—a period that predates Donald Trump—the party has become a proponent of state intervention, an isolationist foreign policy agenda, the subverter of tax laws and personal freedoms, all underpinned by an alarming strain of nativism.

    So how did this dramatic turn come about? It is a question that Alberta seeks to answer across the pages of his weighty, but seldom boring, tome. 

    The case: At the centre of Alberta’s argument is the idea, foretold in the sub-title of his book, that the GoP has been at war with itself and its founding ideals – a conflict of ideas and beliefs that have transformed the party, leaving in its wake fertile ground for the likes of Steve Bannon and Donald Trump to grow and flourish. 

    So where were the seeds of this civil war first sown? 

    Ironically, given his bête noire status in the Trump universe, Alberta points the finger at the decision by the Republican Party and its presidential candidate John McCain, in 2008, to appoint Sarah Palin as his vice-president nominee (wholly under-qualified as a candidate, Pailin was nonetheless reputed to be a deft-hand at moose skinning). It was, Alberta reasons, a fatefully decision that saw the GoP embrace the populist wing of blue collar, male America—a group increasingly marginalized on the fraying edges of the American dream—for the first time. Writes the author:

    “Practically overnight, Sarah Palin came to embody the most disruptive “ism’ of them all, one that would reshape the GoP for a decade to come: populism.”

     [To be fair to McCain he wished to select Joe Lieberman as his running mate, but Lieberman’s pro-choice stance on abortion made him untenable to the GoP base]

    This is, of course, just a starting point. What followed was a grass-roots Republican ‘revolution’ that saw the rise of the rightwing Tea Party; the emergence of the ‘birther’ movement (supported by Donald Trump); and onward, the rise of Trump and his bulldozed path through the primaries, then his presidency and the three years of disruption, chaos and mixed achievements that have followed (as Alberta points out, beside a certain wall, Trump has been surprisingly successful in accomplishing his campaign pledges).

    Personally I am not convinced by Alberta’s claim that the Republican ‘turn’ is necessarily recent in origin. Rather I think that there is a strong case to be made that it started earlier, in 1968, with the failed effort by the liberal Republican candidate, Nelson Rockefeller, to capture the GoP nomination (it was won by Richard Nixon). In this dramatic year the party’s liberal wing found itself orphaned when Rockefeller imploded on the nomination trail, his demise heralding an uninterrupted era in which the party has failed, ever since, to nominate a moderate for president or vice-president. In short, the arrival of Nixon embedded a new ideological stance in the GoP, creating a conservative party in which moderates and their ideas remain marginalized fifty-one years on. 

    In classic ‘civil war’ style American Carnage recalls the tragedies and victims of the conflict: Paul Ryan, speaker of the house, forced to compromise his beliefs in order to steer laws through Congress; Michael Cohen, Trump’s disgraced ‘fixer’, whose past financial improprieties were laid bare by the Mueller Inquiry; James Comey (Former FBI head), Jeff Sessions (Attorney General), and even ‘Sloppy Steve’ Bannon, whose love of the spotlight was intolerable to a president who craves the centre of the stage. The fate of these individuals and others who fell foul of Donald Trump indicate the degree to which the GoP has become subverted to his will – a president demanding undying loyal with the power to disrupt and upend careers, families, stock markets, allies and enemies with a single tweet. 

    But Alberta shows that not everyone has gone quietly into the night. An example is Mitt Romney, a man who openly questioned Trump’s nomination, earning him the now infamous tweeter storm, but who stood by his beliefs and returned to Congress as a junior senator in 2018. He is a man clearly out of step within the new Party of Trump (PoT), a Shakespearean Lear wailing against the excesses of his party’s president.

    American Carnage does carry some noteworthy gaps. Arguably the most important is an understanding of the cultural and socio-economic factors that provided the fuel for the rightward turn of the GoP. In fairness the scrutiny of these origins would require another book, with others have done a fair job of setting out the societal changes that have nurtured ‘Trumpism’. Personally I suggest George Packer’s The Unwinding, J.D. Vance’s Hillbilly Elegy, Amy Goldstein’s Janesville: An American Story, and for those prepared to go back a decade, Joe Bageant’s underrated Deer Hunting with Jesus.

    But even these writers cannot answer certain questions that, before reading American Carnage, I could not answer. Foremost here is the question of the support Donald Trump enjoys from fundamental Christians – backing that seems immune from his less-than Christian indiscretions (Stormy Daniels and Access Hollywood anyone). Alberta lays the answer out clearly in three words: Supreme Court judges. 

    To wit: by supporting the nomination of arch-conservative, pro-life judges Trump—a man who has personally expressed pro-choice values—has steered the American Supreme Court towards the holy grail of the staunch Christian right – the overturning of Roe vs. Wade (the landmark ruling protecting the constitutional right to abortion). With two conservative judges already appointed during his term and new appointment possibilities in the wind, a challenge to the ruling appears imminent.

    Again, on the matter of campaign pledges, Trump can be said to have delivered. Yet in the background the words of Alexander Dubček, the de facto leader of the Prague Spring (Czechoslovakia) come to mind:

    “To disregard moral principles in the realm of politics would be a return to the law of the jungle.”

    And selling your soul comes at a price; a point made clear by the the 2018 mid-term elections when a retreat of affluent suburbanites from the Republican Party helped the Democrats recaptured the House of Representatives. This trend, alongside an ethic shift in American society, wherein the sum of minorities will soon out number the previous white majority, forewarn of telling times for the GoP. The risk for the party, Alberta reasons, is that Trump’s ethnic baiting could turn sufficient voters away from the GoP that years in the electoral wilderness will follow. It is an important argument that raises the question of what a post-Trump Republican Party may need to become in order to survive.

    And what of the future for the other party – the Democrats – who have been energerised by the arrival of younger, social media suave blood into its ranks. Here Alberta’s makes it simple: Trump will seek to demonise the party’s left-leaning progressives by labelling them ‘socialists’, and then use this declaration to tarnish the entire Democrat party, and then watch as his ideologically unsophisticated base balk at a perceived ‘red’ threat to America (author’s note: American Carnage was published before the recent altercation between Trump and the three-women group of Democrats known colloquially as the ‘Squad’).

    It is a tactic that the older guard, Nancy Patricia Pelosi et al, is seeking to deflect. Yet the appearance of these internal differences suggest that the Democrats face a milder version of a civil war themselves – one fought between its older, pragmatic centralist members and the younger, energized followers of the ‘new new left’. And without agreement on a shared path Trump, the artful tweeter of discontent, will use these differences to fracture efforts by the Democrats to recapture the Whitehouse in 2020. 

    But for the bulk of us, by-standers to this American tragicomedy, the situation can seem bewildering and nonsensical; yet we remain aware that our fate is entangled in this unworldly mess (think climate change and trade tariffs). Eldridge Cleaver, the African American activist, presaged this situation in his 1968 treatise Soul On Ice:

    “It is not an overstatement to say that the destiny of the entire human race depends on what is going on in America today. This is a staggering reality to the rest of the world; they must feel like passengers in a supersonic jet liner who are forced to watch helplessly while a passel of drunks, hypes, freaks, and madmen fight for the controls and the pilot’s seat.” 

    Returning to Alberta’s thesis, in a 2018 TIME opinion piece Charles Skyes reasoned that political entities seldom lurch dramatically from one form of ideas and identity to another: “usually” he writes “it is a gradual process of compromises that make sense in the moment, but which have a cumulative effect — like a frog being gradually boiled.” The story laid out across American Carnage suggests that this argument may only be half-true, given the changes that have occurred over the short period of the Trump era.

    But correct or not Tim Alberta has done us a favour by setting out the paths that have brought us to our current point, while providing us with a sense of what lies ahead.

    To end, if one wishes to find some comfort at the end of American Carnage it might be found in the past words of another American, the historian Samuel Eliot Morison, a man whose faith in the regenerative capacity of his nation’s culture and its political system remained unblemished by historical events: 

     “ We have passed through abnormal periods before this, periods of disorder and violence that seemed horrendous and insoluble at the time. Yet we survived as a nation. The genius of our democracy is its room for compromise, our ability to balance liberty with authority. And I am convinced that we will strike a new balance this time, and achieve in the process a new awareness of human relationships among our people.”

    Me? I’m not so sure . . .

  • Traitor, Patriot, Sympathiser?

    Traitor, Patriot, Sympathiser?

    Punji Trap: Pham Xuan An: The Spy Who Didn’t Love Us.
    A Review

    Author: Luke Hunt

    Although the final shots were officially fired in April 1975 the Second Indo-Chinese war (the ‘Vietnam War’ to most) continues to yield stories and controversy, even as a growing number of its participants fade from the stage. Pham Xuan An is one such figure (An died in 2006). Born in southern Vietnam, An worked for the western press, filing copy out of Saigon for Reuters and, later, TIME, while clandestinely fulfilling his responsibilities as a communist sympathiser and agent – in short, a spy. 

    Luke Hunt is the latest writer to tackle An’s story and legacy – and what a tale it is, An emerging from Hunt’s book as, perhaps, the most significant figure of the Vietnam War that you have never heard of. And not just any man, for An was a figure around which many of the pivotal events and personalities of the conflict osculated. To help us understand An’s character and motivations Hunt digs deep into Vietnamese history and the man’s life, starting with An’s childhood in the lower Mekong— including his years as a teenage guerrilla fighting the French—college years in California, his experiences in Saigon during the Vietnam War and, later, through the years that followed unification; until finally, with the turn of the final page, we see An’s life for what it was – lived on the edge but at the centre of history.  

    However Punji Trap is more than a biography of one man, central to Hunt’s book are a cast of wider characters—Vietnamese politicians and schemers (including the fearsome Madame Nhu), a coterie of colourful western journalists (Tim Page, Jim Pringle and Neil Davies) – even an Australian goose feather entrepreneur makes an appearance. The result is a volume that adds further colour and texture to the canvas of Vietnamese affairs during the most traumatic time in this country’s history. A worthy addition to the cannon of Vietnam War-era writing, Hunt has done us all a service by updating An’s story, while adding further clarity to the events that this enigmatic figure helped shape. 

    Luke Hunt: A word from the author

    How did you come to choose the story of Pham Xuan An as the subject for your second book? What things, in particular, attracted you to his story?

    Actually, it was the first book I started and the last to finish. I was always fascinated by the Vietnam War, initially for personal reasons and later it became professional. I met people who knew the inside story of Pham Xuan An, particularly from the journalists perspective and began researching him when there was very little known about An for an undergraduate thesis in 1989. It grew from there and trips to Vietnam and many interviews with An, and those that knew him, followed. Most importantly was the manipulations of media perceptions about the battles fought, and how they were undermined by An, that was most enticing. The Vietnam War remains a very misunderstood conflict and Pham Xuan An is largely responsible for that and arguable the final outcomes. 

    Pham Xuan An has been the previous topic of a book—Larry Berman’s Perfect Spy – The Incredible Double Life of Pham Xuan An—how does your story differ and add to Berman’s account? 

    Those books came long after I began my research, which initially was clandestine. I think An will be one of those characters in history who will spawn many a book, and already there are others. The difference between my effort and other publications is that I did interview many of the people who worked closely with An, particularly in the newsrooms and especially people Pham Ngoc Dinh who worked with An at Reuters. Also other books have stayed close to Hanoi’s official line, which is sometime oblique and does not always tally with what actually happened and how he worked. An was the top ranked spy for the communists and the nature of his business meant his entire professional life was spent in Western news rooms and not the corridors of power in Hanoi. It was the people on the ground in Saigon who had an understanding for what happened and they helped formed the basis for the Punji Trap.

    You are doing a HOWL event [Ed. Cambodia’s dedicated pop-up dedicated to celebrating and promoting the ‘word’] on the 23rd of July, in Siem Reap. What can the audience expect from an ‘encounter’ with Mr. Hunt?

    I’m never really too sure myself, it depends on the audience. These sorts of nights are nearly always unpredictable but often full of laughs. The online world has generated enormous interest in journalism and the wider media game and I’ve often found people are keen to know how it works — perceptions versus the reality — and hopefully they will take home a few thoughts that matter. I enjoy having questions thrown at me.

  • ‘Three Women’                           Is this the ‘book of the year’?

    ‘Three Women’ Is this the ‘book of the year’?

    Check out the review by our own ‘divine Ms. O’, coming soon.

    ‘A masterpiece at the same level as In Cold Blood‘ ELIZABETH GILBERT

  • Otautahi, Christchurch,          I am thinking of you.

    Otautahi, Christchurch, I am thinking of you.

    I am a Kiwi abroad, a Christchurch native, one of the million or so New Zealanders who have found themselves scattered across the various corners of the globe, my home, for now, Siem Reap, Cambodia. 

    Yesterday, 15thMarch, started like any normal Friday for me – a run and breakfast, followed by a quick trawl of the websites back home. ‘Home’, it’s a strange concept living so far away. This century I have spent more time away from the plains of Canterbury, the long straight avenues of the Garden City and the parched February hills of Banks Peninsula than I have lived amongst them. But the spirit of Otautahi maintains a hold on me, the sense of home running deeper than the roots of the old-growth totara of Deans Bush.

    At 7:00 AM (1:00 PM NZT) the lead stories on the web were of the climate strike and the weekend’s Super 15 games, with a measles outbreak the matter of biggest concern in Christchurch. Two hours later, at 9:00 AM, refreshing the page I was greeted by ‘breaking news’, the note brief, a report of a shooting and fatalities at a Christchurch mosque. I paused and tried to recall my ex-home town’s geography—I knew this mosque—I had run, driven and cycled past it many times, the low slung building with its tall minaret part of the city’s fabric to me. 

    This was just the start and through the rest of the day events unfolded like a surreal and violent movie, the stories accompanied by images that featured macabre contrasts: blood stained trousers and the lush green of Hagley Park, white bandages on dark bitumen, bronze coloured bullets across well-cut grass verges. And in the space of a few hours the city I considered quiet, conservative, a bit ‘uptight’ had joined the global ‘atrocity list’—New York, Paris, Marseille, Manchester, Pittsburgh, London—places where hate and weapons have morphed into unthinkable violence against our follow humans. 

    Across websites various stories spoke of a ‘lost innocence’—supported by the ‘welcome to the real world’ comments of various ‘experts’, a number who seemed unable to contain their smugness at being proven right—as if the events of the day are how life is meant to be. In my heart I am not convinced that Christchurch or New Zealand have ever been as naïve as they suggest, but rather like humans the world over, be it matters of natural disaster or acts of terror, it is only when the ground shakes or when shots are fired that the reality becomes just that – real – and we are forced to deal with the consequences. Yet there is nothing that says it has to be or remain that way. I hope people remember that.  


    Last evening I sat on my own and tried to make sense of what had unfolded. In between tears the occasional Cambodian friend chose to message me with questions, one asking ‘Is New Zealand a violent place?’ another querying, ‘how come it happened in New Zealand?’ Living in a country where nearly 2 million people perished during the Khmer Rouge I felt unable to reply about violence in my native home. Perhaps I could have told them about the underlying menace that I often felt on the streets of the Garden City or of the people who had threatened, back in my DJ’ing days, to put ‘burning crosses on my lawn’ because I played too much ‘black music’. But these replies seemed insufficient, just snapshots from a larger picture, a picture that will be studied more closely in the weeks and months to come.

    From afar there are also things to hold precious about the last 48 hours. The bravery of the country’s police, the professionalism of its health providers, the binding of community— irrespective of race, gender or religion—in displays of compassion and a grief shared; and a PM who, when speaking to a man who has done more than most to foster hate, spoke of the need for love. From here it seems that, as Kiwis, it is only when events tear away our facades, bring us to our true selves, that we become the people we strive to show the world: open and inclusive, a people able to hug and cry in the street.

    ——–

    It is mid-afternoon of the day after and I can hear the chanting of monks, the sound of rosters and a wedding party down my unpaved road. It is 31oand Cambodia rural life goes on outside the window where I type. A mood of disbelief remains with me about what has happened an equator and a tropic line away. But my hope is that one-day, should I return, that the events of March 15th will not have seen Christchurch or New Zealand turn inward; that the quest to find answers and fashion responses has not been tainted by politics or knee-jerk reactions; that in answering the horror of that early autumn day the country has become stronger and better – a place where the seeds of hate, ignorance and prejudice are unable to germinate and flourish. If New Zealand and Christchurch manages this then it will have emerged from this tragedy a better place: a place that I remain proud to call ‘home’. 

    Otautahi, Christchurch, I am thinking of you.